Mongolian Human Rights Watch

Political Prisoners Arrested for Silent Protest

2008-08-06T18:56:00.000-07:00

Yesterday, on August 5, 2008, Ms. Saruul, leader of the Mongolian Green Movement, and Mr. Arslan, leader of the Just Citizens' Movement, were arrested by the police for staging a quiet protest by sitting on the Sukhbaatar Square to demand that the authorities release over 200 political prisoners arrested during and after the election riots of July 1-2 and that the government get to the bottom of the shooting and killing unarmed citizens on the night of July 1.

This past month, since the announcement of the State of Emergency in response to preventable violence outside the former communist party building on July 1-2, has been characterised by outright violations of civic and political rights of citizens, arbitrary actions by the police, political persecution of opposition leaders, and media censorship despite the lifting of the state of emergency.

We are calling on all partners inside and outside Mongolia to support non-partisan civil society action for human rights of Mongolian citizens, especially our civic and political rights and demand that the government immediately cease political persecution of innocent citizens, opposition leaders and civil society activists.

Undarya Tumursukh

Asian Focal Point for the International Civil Society Forum for Democracy

International support for The Coalition

2008-07-08T20:44:00.000-07:00

A number of organisations have expressed their support for The Coalition and their statement of July 6th regarding reports of human rights violations during and following the state of emergency in Mongolia (see below).

These organisation are:

Taiwan Association for Human Rights (TAHR)
Ain o Salish Kendra (ASK), Bangladesh
Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC), Nepal
People's Watch, India
Gabriela Women's Party, Philippines
Asian Pacific Forum on Women Law and Development (APWLD)
Asia-Japan Women's Resource Centre, Japan
Community Trust Fund, Sri Lanka
Korea Women's Hot Line, Korea
Asian Forum for Human Rights and Development (FORUM-ASIA)
Human Rights Centre Citizens against corruption, Kyrgyzstan
Institute of Peace and Democracy, Azerbaijan
Foundation for Women, Law and Rural Development (FORWARD), Thailand
Banglar Manabadhikar Suraksha Mancha (MASUM), India
National Commission for Justice and Peace (NCJP), Pakistan
Tibetan UN Advocacy, Switzerland
Centre for Organisation Research and Education (CORE)
Odhikar, Bangladesh
Commitee for Asian Women (CAW)

HRSEMPC Statement - reports of human rights violations

2008-07-07T04:04:00.000-07:00

Human Rights under State of Emergency Monitoring and Protection Coalition

STATEMENT

July 6, 2008 Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia

The history of humankind has demonstrated time and time again that the likelihood of serious human rights violations is increased during a state of emergency. In light of this, over 20 human rights NGOs formed a coalition and pulled their resources to monitor human rights violations, prevent further violence and inform the public during the 4 day state of emergency that was announced on the night of July 1, 2008 following the election protests that took place in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia.

Over 100 people including lawyers, defense attorneys, psychologists, social workers, students and other human rights activists came together on a voluntary basis and conducted monitoring and fact-finding activities on the situation of the 718 detainees arrested during the state of emergency. At the same time, coalition members have also begun to provide legal counseling, relevant information and other services to the detainees and their families.

Within the framework of this monitoring, the coalition members visited the detention sites and hospitals, and met with relevant authorities, the arrested, the injured and their family members. Information collected through interviews, supported by audio and visual documentation, demonstrates that the following violations of human rights and international conventions, to which Mongolia is a signatory, were committed in the process of the organization and implementation of the President’s Decree on Announcing the State of Emergency:

Complete and timely measures were not taken to inform citizens who were unable to receive information through radio and television about the announcement of the state of emergency
The police and army corps were not provided with guidelines on how to perform the arrests in compliance with relevant laws and regulations
In violation of the law, the police and army corps performed a mass arrest, using excessive force, severely beating and injuring people
The detainees were kept in conditions that do not satisfy minimum standards. In particular:

30-50 people were kept in a small room of about 20 square meters, without sufficient air, people were also kept en masse in a detention center garage
Children and women were kept with adult men
The detention rooms did not satisfy minimum health and hygiene standards
The detainees were not allowed access to toilet facilities, which resulted in damage to their health
The detainees were not provided with necessary nutrition. For example, in some detention sites, people were not given food or water for a whole day while in other sites they were given a small piece of cookie with tap water on the first day and chloramine-tainted tea on the second day.
People who required medical attention were not provided with necessary assistance.

During the mass arrests, the Law on Criminal Procedure was seriously violated. In particular:

The detainees were not informed of their rights or the reason for their arrest
The families were not immediately notified about the arrests
During the arrests and the interrogations, the police did not inform citizens of their basic rights such as the right to have a lawyer present and the right not to testify against oneself
People with disabilities and children were interrogated without the presence of a parent, legal guardian, representative or lawyer
The detainees were forced to give and sign statements under torture and duress
Television footage is being used as stand-alone evidence and repeatedly broadcast on the Mongolian National Public Television and Radio.

As a result of the above violations, the detainees and their family members and friends have suffered severe psychological damage over and above significant material losses. Even after 5 days have passed since the initial arrests, there are over 70 people who have not been located and their family and friends are still looking for them.

Given these serious and numerous violations of international human rights laws such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, International Pact on Civil and Political Rights, Rome Statute on the International Criminal Court, and the International Convention against Torture and Inhuman Treatment, the Constitution of Mongolia and the Law of Mongolia on Criminal Procedure, lead us to conclude that the on-going interrogation process is illegal.

Basic human rights principles, which dictate that no one may be subjected to torture, inhuman treatment, humiliation and cruel punishment, must be strictly followed at all times. Violation of these principles can not be justified under any circumstances. Therefore, we demand that egregious violations of human rights and freedoms be stopped immediately.

The temporary closure of all broadcast media with the exception of the Mongolian National Public Radio and Television resulted in a dire lack of objective and timely information. In the context of an already distressed and anxious public, this unbalanced and one-sided information further increased people’s fears and severely undermined their trust in state protection. These events have clearly demonstrated the fragility of Mongolia’s democratic institutions and the weaknesses of Mongolia’s national human rights protection mechanisms.

For these reasons we call on the government, political parties, citizens and civil society organizations to make a concerted effort to resolve the current situation peacefully, based on human rights, to restore and protect the rights of our citizens who have been affected by the mass arrests, and to strengthen human rights guarantees in Mongolia. It is of vital importance that we work together to protect and ensure fundamental human rights in Mongolia.

Center for Human Rights and Development

Law and Human Rights Center

National Center against Violence

Open Society Forum

Globe International

Philanthropy for Development Center

Mongolian Women’s Fund

Step by Step NGO

“Let’s Develop” Club

Amnesty International Mongolia

Citizen D.Lamjav

Mongolian Women’s Federation

Mongolian Men’s Association

“Mongolian Family” Psychotherapy Association

National Federation of Disabled Citizens’ Unions

Association for Family Wellbeing

Center for Citizens’ Alliance

Liberty Center

Asian Focal Point for the International Civil Society Forum for Democracy

Korean-Mongolian Democracy Cooperation Team express concern on state of human rights after the emergency situation in Mongolia

2008-07-04T19:40:00.000-07:00

Statement from the Korea-Mongolia Democracy Cooperation Team

Korean-Mongolian Democracy Cooperation Team Express concern on Post-election Conflict in Mongolia

July 4^th,2008

We, the Korean-Mongolian Democracy Cooperation Team are deeply concerned about the current political situation in Mongolia following the parliamentary election on June 29^th 2008. As we observed the political and social turmoil during the stay in Mongolia, we found out that this is not only the problem of political corruption, but also the problem of growing rich and poor divide.

Eruption of violence after the public protest against fraudulent election has leaved several people dead and many people injured. We believe that suppressing the protesters by Mongolian government and banning all the media except the Mongolian Public Radio and TV will deteriorate the political development and human rights.

We, Korean-Mongolian Democracy Cooperation Team would like to endorse the other pro-Democracy NGOs in Mongolia that are now struggling for the fair election, political development and human rights in Mongolia.

UN Human Right's Office concerned for detainees

2008-07-04T19:36:00.000-07:00

Media release from the United Nations Human Rights Office regarding the state of emergency in Mongolia.

United Nations human rights office concerned about developments in Mongolia

July 3^rd, 2008

GENEVA-- The United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) on Thursday expressed concerns about developments in Mongolia, where a four-day state of emergency was imposed on 1 July 2008 following post-electoral violence. There have been reports of at least five deaths, numerous injuries and around 700 protestors detained.

OHCHR called upon the authorities to exercise the utmost restraint, to ensure that due process is followed in the case of any detentions, and that the incidents leading to deaths and injuries be properly investigated.

Mongolia is party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights which stipulates that fundamental rights, such as the right to life, the prohibition on torture and cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment, cannot be suspended even in times of emergency. Any restrictions of other rights in such circumstances must be officially proclaimed and may only be applied to the extent and duration strictly warranted by the circumstances.

WFDA urge Mongolian government to uphold fundamental human rights

2008-07-04T19:34:00.000-07:00

Statement from the World Forum on Democratization in Asia regarding post election conflict in Mongolia.

Asian Democrats express concern about Post-election conflict in Mongolia

3rd July, 2008

The World Forum on Democratization in Asia (WFDA) is gravely concerned about recent developments in Mongolia following the parliamentary elections on 29 June, notably the eruption of violence among protests of alleged election fraud and the imposition on 1 July of a four-day state of emergency by President Nambariin Enkhbayar in the capital of Mongolia, Ulaanbataar.

Although Mongolia’s General Election Committee has yet to report the final results, preliminary results suggest that the ruling Mongolian People’s Revolutionary Party (MPRP) has won a significant majority in the 76-seat parliament. However, allegations of fraud have been raised by opposition parties and some independent candidates. An initially peaceful protest quickly deteriorated into a violent confrontation between angry young men and police outside MPRP headquarters.

WFDA firmly repudiates the violent acts carried out by all those involved in Monday’s bloody confrontation, which resulted in at least five deaths and 300 injuries. We are particularly disturbed by reports that party leaders on both sides may have had a hand in the provocation of violence, as well as allegations that the police did not take effective steps to calm the situation at an early stage. WFDA calls on all political actors to exercise restraint and cease incitement of their supporters, and urges security forces to fulfill their obligation to preserve and protect the fundamental rights of the Mongolian public.

We are also concerned about the widespread allegations of electoral fraud, and we call on the General Election Committee and related authorities to investigate all credible accusations thoroughly and impartially. If necessary, the Committee should delay the publication of final results to allow these investigations to be carried out properly. Such steps are urgently needed to address voters’ legitimate concerns and to restore confidence in the election process.

Finally, we also urge the Mongolian government to continue to uphold fundamental human rights during the current state of emergency, including the rights of the more than 700 people detained in connection with these events, who are reportedly at risk of inhumane treatment. In addition, we call on President Enkhbayar to lift the ban on all radio and television channels other than Mongolian National Public Radio and Television. In this critical period, media and civil society groups must, if anything, redouble their efforts to hold the government and security forces accountable.

The post-election turmoil reveals the deep-seated problems of Mongolia’s young democracy. Therefore, WFDA strongly supports continued efforts by Mongolian civil society organizations to protect and promote democracy, human rights, and peace in Mongolia.

Statement to the Directors of the Mongolian National Public Radio and Television - please be objective

2008-07-04T05:38:00.000-07:00

The following is a statement made by seven Human Rights NGOs to the Directors of the Mongolian National Public Radio and Television.

Human Rights NGOs’ Statement

July 1, 2008

To: Mr. Naranbaatar, General Director, Mongolian National Public Radio and Television

Mr. Munkhbaatar, Director, Mongolian National Public Television

Mr. Purevdash, Director, Mongolian National Public Radio

At this time when all radio and television channels except for the Mongolian National Public Radio and Television have been temporarily shut down in connection to the declaration of the State of Emergency, it is ever more important that the MNRTV dutifully carry out its responsibility to serve the people’s interests.

During this critical time when the anger and frustration of people accumulated as a result of over 10 years of injustice, corruption and electoral fraud have peaked to the point of violent outbursts, further provoked by the illegal proceedings of the most recent national election, the MNTRTV should:

- operate with full understanding of its role as an organization “whose sole duty is to serve the interests of the public, which is accountable to the public and conducts its activities under the public oversight”

- strictly follow its basic principles of operation and “be independent, respect citizens’ right to obtain information, respect plurality of opinion and transparency, and put common national interests above those of economic entities, organizations, officials, individuals and political parties”

- and conduct its operations according to Article 9.1 of the Law on National Public Radio and Television, which states that “the programming of the public radio and television must contain truthful and objective information, be professionally developed, not be one-sided, strictly abide by the journalists’ code of ethics and be timely.”

That the MNRTV operates strictly according to these principles and legal provisions is of crucial importance for restoring peace, preventing further violations of human rights, and resolving the conflicts through peaceful means while maintaining national unity.

We are deeply worried that in the last few days, MNTV programming has been markedly one-sided and biased in favor of the power-holders. We hope the MNTV shall correct this mistake immediately for the benefit of the people of Mongolia and perform its public duty with honor, according to the law and constitutional principles.

Center for Citizens’ Alliance

Center for Human Rights and Development

National Center against Violence

Center for Human Rights and Law

Mongolian Women’s Fund

“Tsekh” Constitutional Watchdog NGO

Asian Focal Point for International Civil Society Forum for Democracy

Civil Society Statement - regret

2008-07-04T05:29:00.000-07:00

The following is a statement made by 10 civil society groups in Mongolia about the public protest that took place on July 1^st 2008.

Civil Society Statement

July 2, 2008 Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia

We deeply regret about the violence that erupted after the public protest on July 1, 2008, leaving several people dead, many injured, and valuable public and private property destroyed, including precious cultural artifacts. We believe this violence was an extreme expression of deep-seated anger and frustration accumulated by significant sections of the society as a result of persistent injustice and corruption.

We regret that during this critical time of public unrest and violence, political parties are seeking to maximize their political gain in pursuit of their narrow interests with no regard for people’s lives and human rights and freedoms.

We regret that the government failed to accurately assess the situation and take proper measures in a timely fashion. The violent confrontation between citizens and the police demonstrated a tragic lack of the police leadership’s conflict management capacity and skills.

We hold that the restrictions imposed on inalienable human rights are excessive and unnecessary. In particular, we believe that the restrictions imposed on citizens’ rights to free expression and information by closing all radio and television channels except for the Mongolian National Public Radio and Television and blocking major news websites were unjustified.

We are deeply concerned about the safety of over 700 people arrested during the riot as reports are coming in from their family members about torture and inhuman treatment by the police. We demand access to the detention sites to monitor the human rights abuses against the detainees, many of whom are reportedly under-age. We demand that the detainees’ right to legal representation be fully ensured.

Furthermore, we demand that all possible measures be taken immediately to identify and persecute those responsible for the heinous crime of shooting 3 people to death with a fire-arm. We are shocked by the report that one of the victims was shot in the back while running away from the riot site.

We hold that the use of force against demonstrators, rioters and observers without having properly communicated to them the Declaration of the State of Emergency was a serious violation of human rights.

We believe that this incidence was a manifestation of the loss of faith on the part of many Mongolians in the possibility of peaceful and fair resolution of conflicts in the Mongolian society. Therefore, we call on the government, all political parties, citizens and civil society organizations to join efforts towards strengthening of Mongolia’s democratic institutions and restoring citizens’ faith in the electoral process.

- Open Society Forum

- Center for Human Rights and Development

- Globe International NGO

- Philanthropy for Development Center

- Human Rights and Law Center

- Mongolian Women’s Fund

- Asian Focal Point for the International Civil Society Forum for Democracy

- Human Rights and Democracy Research Center

- National Center against Violence

- Center for Citizens’ Alliance

National Election, Mongolia June - July 2008

2008-07-04T03:30:00.000-07:00

The chain of events…

On Sunday 29^th of June Mongolia held its national election.

On Monday 30^th of June during the initial counting of the votes many electoral observers and Mongolian citizens begun reporting cases of electoral fraud.

In preliminary counts it appeared that the Mongolian People’s Revolutionary Party (MPRP) had the majority of seats, thus indicating victory. This result is being strongly questioned and contested by citizens, media, opposition forces and civil society.

In response to these allegations of electoral fraud citizens organised gatherings in order to protest the election results. Soon after, the Democratic Party and the smaller parties joined these gatherings.

On Tuesday 1^st of July protesters gathered at Sukhbaatar square outside the Mongolian Parliamentary Building. Later that afternoon, the protesters marched to the MPRP building where they were met by a wall of riot police armed with batons.

Over ten thousand people participated in the peaceful protest. Towards the evening however some of the protesters, mostly young men, became involved in a violent confrontation with the police. The violence escalated due to poor management on behalf of police leadership, and a large number of disenfranchised youth who appear to have joined the disorder. This situation resulted in the burning, looting and significant damage of the MPRP building, surrounding area and property. The police retaliated with the use of tear gas and rubber bullets.

(Image found on flickr 'william...'s')

During the protest and subsequent violence 718 people were arrested, over 60 people sustained serious injuries and five deaths were reported. Serious concern surrounds three of these deaths as it is alleged real bullets caused the deaths.

On Tuesday July 2^nd at midnight, the Mongolian President N. Enkhbayar issued a four-day state of emergency. According to the decree:

1. To strengthen the security of objects of state significance.

2. Using forces permitted by the law, to break up any kinds of demonstrations and mass activities arranged with infringing the law.

3. To restrict the traffic movement in the central part of the capital and check motor vehicles.

4. Using forces, to disperse and arrest persons and groups of people who break the public order and arrange actions with use of forces and examine whether they have arms and technical devices.

5. To impose a curfew from 22.00 p.m. to 08.00 a.m. in the central part of the capital; to check persons breaking it; to arrest individuals having no ID cards with forces of the police or military patrol in the period until the end of the state of emergency or for 72 hours after having been identified.

6. To ban the use of sound devices such as loudspeakers and to stop activities of all television and radio outlets with the exception of the national public television and radio service until the end of the state of emergency.

7. To prohibit the sale and distribution of alcoholic beverages.

8. To monitor individuals with access to firearms and cold steel, over entities and plants using explosives, virulent chemicals, and radioactive substances, and over military arms and techniques used in training.

9. To charge the Minister of Justice and Internal Affairs Ts. Monkh-Orgil with the responsibility of organising all actions for implementing the decree.

(Image found on flickr 'william...'s')

Fear of Violations of Human Rights

There is now great concern for the safety of 718 women, men and children arrested during the riots. Reports are being received from family members regarding the inhuman treatment and torture of detainees currently being held in detention.

Due to the limited media coverage and concerns for the human rights of the detainees, civil organisations within Mongolia are working together to advocate and ensure their ongoing welfare.

This blog has been set up as an alternative form of media in order to provide information on the current human rights issues in Mongolia. It is also hoped that the dissemination of this information will encourage transparency and accountability to ensure human rights are upheld during and after the current state of emergency.